KCD2: Best Outcome for Semine and Hashek

Necessary Evil presents one of KCD2's most morally complex main quests, forcing players to make difficult choices. If you're struggling with whether to support Semine or Hashek in this pivotal decision, here's a complete breakdown.

Kingdom Come Deliverance 2 Necessary Evil Quest Walkthrough

Following the Back in the Saddle quest, von Bergow assigns Hans and Henry to investigate Nebakov Fortress, including interrogating a prisoner. Your interrogation approach significantly impacts whether forces target Semine or Nebakov.

Prisoner Interrogation Answers

During interrogation, successfully pass these Speech checks:

• "We can advocate for leniency" (Requires 20 Impression)
• "Istvan and I go way back" (Requires 20 Impression)
• "Refusing won't end well for you" (Requires 17 Intimidation)

Alternatively, use torture instruments to extract information. Your choices here determine whether forces assault Semine or Nebakov Fortress.

Semine vs Nebakov: Which to Attack?

Choosing Nebakov concludes the quest immediately with von Bergow handling the bandits. Opting for Semine leads to more complex moral dilemmas involving Hashek. While attacking Nebakov avoids Semine's bloodshed, it lets Semine escape consequences for aiding bandits.

The Critical Semine vs Hashek Choice

Before the assault, Hashek reveals his vengeful motives against Semine. At the confrontation:

• Support Hashek by selecting "Hashek makes valid points"
• Defend Semine by choosing "Olda merits proper judgment"

We recommend supporting Semine. While complicit, Semine shows remorse, whereas Hashek seeks indiscriminate slaughter. After defeating Hashek, advise the Semines to destroy their estate and flee.

Final Reporting Decision

When debriefing von Bergow:

• Let Hans handle the explanation for optimal outcomes
• Speaking up yourself risks diplomatic complications

Hans' diplomatic skills maintain von Bergow's favor while progressing the narrative toward Nebakov.

For more KCD2 guides including romance options and collectible locations, continue exploring our coverage.